As the song vaguely says, it’s 4 in the morning, and once more a dawning…… the other morning I woke too early because of concerns for others, whether welcomed or not….but this time its about me!
Last night I sent off an email to the SBS Guest Book, in which I reproached Government’s lack of inactivity in recent history, based on three excellent SBS Drama Documentaries of these past weeks…The Age of Aids, 4 Parts – Speer & Hitler, 3 Parts and Do Not Resuscitate, 2 Parts.
I focused on the discrimination arising out of three major disasters which have befallen mankind because “good men stood by and did nothing.”
The first, The Age of Aids saw HIV-Aids pandemic treated initially as a “gay man’s issue” and therefore not worthy of consideration because Governments morality did not meet the standards expected of “good religious folk”…..whether Christian, Buddhists, Hindu, Islamic, Judaism or Eclectic …..Governments would rather deny the reality of the horrific dying, the loss of parents to children, the loss of children to parents, anything but acknowledge the reality of what was obviously a major medical disaster. Those same “Leaders” still went to their various buildings of worship and implored their God to “help them” – but the Institution of Governments who could have done “something”, but did nothing until the man in the street rose up in frustration and anger, demanded their Governments act to improve their health prognosis.
Denial and Discrimination.
The second dramatization, which included genuine footage from various archives told the history of the infamous Albert Speer, an architect, then Hitler’s Armaments Minister, whatever – Narcissism personified, who went on to become a murderer of Jews, Dissentients and others through forced labor, exhaustion and starvation. Of course, for my generation we’ve all seen the footage from WW11, a hundred times. Graphic and horrible, is to understate its impact….(but part of me asks, and what lessons did the Jews learn from their own treatment, to those marginalized people in Palestine. Hitler started by displacing a population he didn’t want around, and the killing has differently continued).
One wrong does not make another right.
That Mr Speer was able to continue for so long in both his role as an revered architect and a Member of the Third Reich without “knowing” that men, women and children were being murdered in their millions, screams “Liar, Liar, Liar”….Again I thought we only have supposition on what relationship Speer had with Hitler, two deluded narcissistic feeding off each other ……whatever it was, it was an unhealthy denial of the facts as he, extremely intelligent would have deduce for himself. I was both fascinated and repulsed by Speer’s defence of “I knew nothing”….It was not my responsible to know the daily crimes committed by others, that ultimately achieved what I wanted in any case. The process was irrelevant, only the target was important, the end product! How this was achieved was not my concern??” He got 20 years in jail.
Denial and Discrimination.
The third dramatization is the current documentary Do Not Resuscitate which will conclude for the general public this evening. As a participant, Activist for Pro Choice along with Steve Guest, terminal cancer patient and Judy Bayliss, a multiple sclerosis 30 year sufferer, I have a personal interest in what this documentary will achieve at State Government levels.
I can equate Steve Guest’s suffering with those seen in the two previously mentioned docos. Whether it is Aids, Starvation or Cancer, Chronic and relentless pain, there is just the brutality and “in your face” graphic imaginary of intense suffering. The dullness of the eyes as all hope of survival and release gradually shut down the body’s sense of joy and hope and reality sets in. That the circumstances the Aids patients finds themselves in (through no fault of their own!), the Jews & Gypsies (through no fault of their own) and then the Steves and Judys (through no fault of their own)., is displaying the same futility.
Television & media in 2006 does not allow Governments to deny all knowledge of what happens elsewhere in the world or even their own State of Victoria’s backyard. Thanks for the SBS and ABC in-depth analysis away from the glitz of showbiz & share markets.
In many cases, Governments compound and are actually responsible for the unmitigated anguish caused to humans through greed, pompous belief in their own importance above their citizens, religious zealots, convenience, or reputation…..The final Glass House Comedy TV Show got their message through if only through humor….the message was clear and accurate….And the audience agreed…we need the young people to replace those older, self deluded representatives of the people. We need people to govern Australia based on scientific facts. We need to worry about our environment, with long term visions not short termed gains.
That a Victorian citizen can receive 14 years jail for assisting a suicide of a frail infirmed person, yet Mr Speer of the Nuremburg trials received twenty years, directly responsible for the death of thousands (because they were only Jews? perhaps) (Like the African Americans, on Death Row)…… just angers me beyond what is good for my health.
I am furious to think that helping a loved one to die is treated as malicious murder, than a man who murdered for gain and “glory” (but then he was probably a very good Christian, you know, like Mel Gibson!) Killing healthy young fit innocent people because of religious convictions and differences has a lot to answer for, yet desperate actions arising out of love, are treated as murder in law, by World Governments.
Denial and Discrimination.
It is never ignorance that leads Governments to “stand by and do nothing”, to sit and the fence, watch, “tut tut”, to mumble “its a shame, a pity, but what can I do?, until someone else brings their concerns to Parliament as a Private Members Bill – but not actually do anything practical themselves. It is self interest – at the expense of those who elected them.
I spoke recently to a doctor who treats HIV and I can understand that the full letter of the Medical Treatment Act 1988 has enabled doctors to fulfill their duty to the patient first and foremost…do no harm, by further treatment, in a hopeless situation. Frankly I am bloody jealous of the freedom that allows a HIV positive person to live their lives in “relative peace” knowing their death can be quick and painless because they have “a kind and genuinely compassionate doctor”… HIV patients quite rightly have access to the doctors who meet their personal needs without judgment, enabling only the patient to be considered their highest priority.
In my email to SBS Guest Book, I said that I would like the same Rights, as is extended to my dog who can be euthanized without pain or distress,following a simple injection. I would like just to be treated like a dog and be allowed to die like a dog when my time comes.
If it is good enough for a cat or a dog – we are all God’s creatures we’re told – (only man thinks he is superior to all other living entities) as the lady said in the restaurant, “I want some of what she’s having”…….only I’ll settle for it anywhere, that is, Nembutal.
Denial and Discrimination against humanity’s suffering by current Victorian legislation is to liken them to previous Governments “I know nothing” because I choose not to see “nothing” because I do not open my eyes and look at “something”…. “I can’t recall that emancipated body?” Look down, look away, look busy, look important, don’t see, don’t care, don’t be aware, Do Nothing!!!
Like Speers of Hitler’s inner circle, like the President of South Africa, Like Mr Bracks, our newly reelected Victorian Labor Premier, who could initiate something but does nothing….Just like many of the Politicians before him…..Blinkered to the point of, not stupidity through ignorance, but inhumanity because he chooses to close his eyes and not step out into the real world to see for himself how people “survive” their illnesses.
A Premier who has “promised” (source SHS Nov 26 p12) to govern for all Victorians, without discrimination. $24 million to improve ambulance times to resuscitate whether wanted or not, $350 million to improve dialysis and cancer treatments in addition to maternity. It is not as if dialysis and cancer are being ignored now…but to lie in the beds provided by the additional 168 mental health beds in suburban hospitals sums it well. Let those of us who wish to have our Living Wills honoured in legislation, choose choice and dignity in dying and free up existing resources for those who will benefit the most. The people who can be cured, want to be cured, wait to be cured, and let other who wait to die, actually do so quickly and painlessly with medically assisted dying.
I particularly liked the savings reported under Cost Cutting, of 20% fewer laws than in 1999.
What about deleting some existing suicide assistance laws thereby making some additional savings in police investigations and court proceeding, involving doctors, journalists, aged and infirmed suspects? And why back to 1999? What happened in between then and now?
Let the religious have their faith that their pain has purpose but for the rest of us, Act! Walk through the corridors of any oncology ward, hospice, nursing home, palliative care unit. Don’t see the flowers, the sparkling sheets, the crisp staff…..see the people….the human beings…and allow them Choice please!
Denial and Discrimination.
In an Age article dated June 20 1996, captioned “Man sues physician who made him live” An American, Ray Noonkester, suffering with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, a degenerative nerve disorder also know as Lou Gehrig’s disease, since 1993, was provided with a respirator to assist with his breathing. He believed it was only temporary relief and that he’d be appropriately medicated in the near future. Having been ill for three years he thought he had his house in order with his Living Will. Because he accepted the immediate solution arising out of his distress gasping for air, the doctor claimed Mr Noonkester had indicated he then wanted to live on indefinitely…….
Hard to make a rational decision when you’re turning blue in the face from lack of air!. Doctor should assume this as read…..one would have thought oxygen imperative to stabilize the condition in order to complete the process of dying by medication.
Hence, my tattoo says DO NOT RESUSCITATE – THANK YOU – VE MEMBER……. No confusion with my living will!
—————————
In closing my diary entry today, I want to share a “moment frozen in time for me”. One of my family members vehemently opposed to my activism for the Pro Choice Lobby told me of a dream they’d had this week, in which I had gone on to develop bone cancer, and they’d agreed after all, to assist me to die.
Of course, it is possible that I may develop bone cancer (thinking of the nagging pain in my left wrist, diagnosed as arthritis), but it is absolutely impossible that I would seek assistance from anyone within my family for dying with dignity. I would never place that pressure on them to break the law – which is why the law needs to be changed. Enough they suffer from my dying, without going to jail for helping me make it peaceful. I must make my own arrangements, however difficult.
What touched me so deeply was the fact that the dream was revealed to me and its outcome for me was positive. It told me that some where in the deepest physic of the brain, change even to the strongest resolve can eventuate if the circumstances are critical. Since viewing the Documentary a major subliminal shift had occurred in someone very very important to me.
———————
And I remembered a friend, focusing intently on my face, who once said very gently…”Instead of saying, “I can’t do that” , think about what would happen, the opportunities possible, arising out of saying “Yes, I can do that”…..